Living in Alfred, NY according to the 1850 Census. Born in Bridgewater, Plymouth Co. MA, according to records from Suzanne Dunbar. Taken from book "The Descendants of Robert Dunbar of Hingham, MA 1630-1693" by Ann Theopold Chaplin, C.G. 1992 Several Robert Dunbar`s are listed there in 1790-1810 Census records. In 1820 Census, Robert Dunbar lived in Eaton, Madison Co. NY, Page 58, Roll 73. Image 6400 . In Eaton, Madison Co. NY, 1840 Census, Roll 295, page 104, Lewis Peet was a resident--the closest I have found to think he might have been thr father of Phebe Peet. Bridgewater, Plymouth Co. MA has Dunbars buried in the Alden graveyard, sometimes called the Great Woods graveyard, lying north side of Taunton River in Bridgeport, below the mouth of Winatuxett River.